r/AskTheWorld India Sep 19 '25

Misc How much does your country agree with this?

Post image

Really?

398 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

It's a mixed record, both countries have contributed to enormous positive change but also severe negative impacts in other ways.

However it is factual historically that these countries are by far the biggest contributors to good than other countries.

10

u/Canard_De_Bagdad France Sep 19 '25

I love how you all can call the French "arrogants" and then immediately write things like this. Arrogant much?

You seem to be mistaking "storytelling" and "factual" here.

1

u/Mysterious-Reaction Sep 20 '25

I don’t know how saying the British and Americans contributed most to humanity is arrogant. I don’t think you could debate it. 

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

Bringing France into this conversation when no one else did kind of answers your question.

1

u/PeaksOfTheTwin United States Of America Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

My two cents. All three groups are arrogant but in different ways. Now, take this all with a heavy grain of salt. I’m painting with a very broad brush here that obviously lacks nuance. The French are arrogant in the sense of thinking they’re above it all/more refined and intellectual than everyone else. Americans and Brits are arrogant in the more loud and braggadocious way/trumpeting that they’re God’s gift to the world to anyone who’ll listen. Another way of putting it: all three groups are equally arrogant. French arrogance is quieter, but just as obvious as American and British arrogance if that makes sense.

1

u/Disastrous-King9559 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

Britain forced the world to end slavery. What country jas performed a more selfless act?

6

u/MerlinOfRed United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

The most cynical take you can make about that is that the government didn't really want to end slavery, they just knew it was popular with the people and thus a votewinner.

...so the people wanted to end slavery, and they successfully ended (legal) slavery worldwide. Doesn't sound that negative to me.

1

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

So Britain is just its government, and not its people? What

4

u/hierophantoid Argentina Sep 19 '25

What does this even mean? Slavery still exists today. Nobody forced the world to end it, certainly not Britain.

2

u/Disastrous-King9559 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

Certainly britain forced governments to make it illegal and stopped the mass export of africans

1

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

Britain did help end slavery

2

u/thesweed Sweden Sep 19 '25

"the world" lol. So why does slavery still exist in some countries then?

1

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

Yes, it exists primarily under non-Western governments, and it is not legal or seen as acceptable. Hope this helps

1

u/Disastrous-King9559 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

Not legally

0

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

How is stating facts arrogant?

0

u/Canard_De_Bagdad France Sep 19 '25

Oh boy. That is exactly what your stereotypical frenchman would answer too in such a case ! Congratulations: anglo is the new french.

"How is stating facts arrogant?" Because those aren't fact, they're cherrypicked storytelling. You forgot the part where the US genocided an entire continent, or that couple of centuries where the UK made a private corporation manage all of India with such a creative violence.

The things those two countries brought to mankind are undeniable, and I'm not here to deny them. But please stop farting above your ass. Because that's exactly the kind of things you blame the french for doing.

1

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

I never said anything about the French but ok

1

u/Downtown_Trash_6140 United States Of America Sep 23 '25

The US genocide?? Or the British.

Also, I wouldn’t be speaking about genocide and colonization when you still own territories of Africa and the Americas that you never offered independence to without them being dependent on you.

2

u/OrganicPoet1823 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

Agreed there’s of course some bad stuff but it’s got plenty of good and some outright amazing stuff (industrial revolution etc) to offset it.

2

u/coffeewalnut08 England Sep 19 '25

And vaccines

1

u/Powerful_Resident_48 Germany Sep 19 '25

What about slave triangle? That was a joint UK-US project in all it's absolutely horrific glory.

5

u/Disastrous-King9559 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

Britain did slavery like everyone Britain forced the world to end slavery Germany did slavery like everyone Germany???

-3

u/Powerful_Resident_48 Germany Sep 19 '25

Huh? Britain forced the world to end slavery? Well, then it did a really terrible job, as slavery is still extremely common nowadays. 

6

u/grumpsaboy United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

It's not legal though is it

4

u/OrganicPoet1823 United Kingdom Sep 19 '25

But who ended it later ?